Best of this Week Summary 30 Sept - 07 Oct 2007

• Interesting and provocative point of view in this blog "Why most large-scale Web sites are not written in Java". Quite an extensive discussion can be followed in this TSS refering post. I think the main reason is that the use of the programming language and stack depends on the requirements of the application. Most of the example websites given do not have serious transactional requirements, including transactions that would run over multiple systems, requiring XA. For those example websites no real big harm is done when a transaction occasionally fails. Note also that most Java/JEE implementations use at least some part of the LAMP stack, like Linux and Apache. See here for other reasons.
  


• Danny Ayers is wondering whether JSON is missing a DTD or XSD. Because if you take an arbitrary JSON document from the Internet, you can't tell what it is containing; and usually you can't find it out either. Is that a good or bad thing? I'd say you've got XML and its associated XSD or DTD for interfaces that require a well-defined interface that can be passed on to other, potentially external, 3rd parties without too much effort. For interfaces that stay internal to your system (for example an AJAX call from the browser to the server), adding the extra overhead of some validation format like an XSD or DTD causes just too much overhead, losing the gain of the compactness of JSON. Data is validated anyway by the frontend and backend, though with a bit more programming effort.